EMBC 2008

Main Menu

  • Home
  • Biology society
  • Engineering
  • International conference
  • Medicine
  • Salary

EMBC 2008

Header Banner

EMBC 2008

  • Home
  • Biology society
  • Engineering
  • International conference
  • Medicine
  • Salary
Biology society
Home›Biology society›The Prime Minister is wrong to ignore the science on gender identity

The Prime Minister is wrong to ignore the science on gender identity

By Ben Delgado
October 1, 2021
0
0

The first chief science adviser to a decentralized Scottish government has denounced the SNP’s stance on Gender Recognition Act (GRA) reform, saying scientific evidence shows sex is binary.

Professor Dame Anne Glover, who was Scotland’s chief science adviser between 2006 and 2011, said proposed reforms that would allow trans women to legally declare themselves as biological women and trans men to declare themselves biological men do not make no sense from a scientific point of view. of view.

In a broad interview with Holyrood, Glover said it’s important to be realistic that trans women biologically remain men and trans men biologically remain women because biology “predisposes us to certain diseases.”

“[A trans woman] is different because she was born sexually as a man – it’s the denial of that that worries me, ”she said.

“It does not concern me that trans women and men want to have their rights verified – this is very valid – but the denial of the basic biology and psychology of women, especially those who have suffered trauma, doesn’t make sense to me. “

Premier Nicola Sturgeon has repeatedly stated that her government wants to reform the GRA to allow people to self-report their gender without any medical evidence to support it. The reforms, which the Scottish Greens have pledged to support as part of their recently sealed cooperation deal with the SNP, would also allow trans people to legally erase all documentary evidence of the gender they were born to.

Many feminist organizations – and SNP politicians, including South West Edinburgh MP Joanna Cherry – oppose the proposals because they believe they would erode women’s rights. However, Sturgeon dismissed these concerns, saying recently in an interview with BBC Radio Scotland that they are “not valid”.

Glover said it doesn’t make sense because it inherently negates science while ignoring what governments are capable of doing independently of science.

“It is valid for the Prime Minister to say that often when making policy there are different types of evidence,” she said.

“Science will be part of it, but there will also be moral, economic, philosophical and political arguments. Why would the Prime Minister say that scientists may be well meaning but they are wrong? I don’t know where the authority comes from to dismiss this specialized knowledge and say “I’m right”.

“It would be fair to say that I accept scientific evidence, but for moral, ethical or political reasons, I am still pursuing the GRA. It’s valid, but you can’t choose science.

In the interview, Glover also discusses how Scotland is leading the way in biotechnology innovation, what it was like to study science at a time when women were supposed to ‘get married and have children’, and how she felt after being ousted from her post as president of the Royal Society of Edinburgh earlier this year.

Read the full interview in the latest issue of Holyrood, released next week.


Source link

Related posts:

  1. How this Hyderabad science society is redefining research for you- Edexlive
  2. City Club of Eugene: The Knight Campus: How the growth of a research juggernaut can change the world
  3. The generation that can make peace with nature
  4. Hope College receives $ 2.5 million gift to prepare students to become global health leaders

Archives

  • May 2022
  • April 2022
  • March 2022
  • February 2022
  • January 2022
  • December 2021
  • November 2021
  • October 2021
  • September 2021
  • August 2021
  • July 2021
  • June 2021

Categories

  • Biology society
  • Engineering
  • International conference
  • Medicine
  • Salary

Recent Posts

  • ENA Respiratory selected for BLUE KNIGHT™ to accelerate
  • Abia health workers block road due to 12 months salary arrears
  • 9th Annual iCons Senior Expo Features Research Findings From Largest Class of Graduates: UMass Amherst
  • Nature Medicine Releases Results of Investigator-Initiated Trial of CARsgen CT041 Claudin18.2 CAR T Cells in Gastrointestinal Cancers
  • Saudi bank customers warned against victims of social engineering fraud
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions